Diego MaradonaArgentina’s new manager, Carlos Bilardo, left, and the team’s new head coach, Diego Maradona, are introduced by Julio Grondona, right, the head of the Argentine Football Association. (Associated Press)

It’s official: Diego Maradona was handed the reins of the Argentina national team Tuesday in a move that “represents a profound, if not reckless, leap of faith,” according to Dan Rosenheck, writing for The Times. But the peculiar move, which came to light more than a week ago, has the chance to be shockingly ingenious if Argentina can reverse its recent form and, imagine it, play beautiful soccer for “El Diego.”

And if Maradona has taught the world one thing, it is never count him out. His teammate on the 1986 World Cup champions, Jorge Valdano, a far more cerebral player than Maradona, said Argentina’s new coach is “a genetic miracle, a man whom nature endowed with extraordinary abilities and who, moreover, grew up in the right place to achieve his potential.” (Read the entire Q & A with Valdano on the BBC’s Web site; it’s great stuff.)

But will Maradona’s undeniable genius translate into success as a coach?

Rob Hughes asks in the International Herald Tribune: “Do they have that capacity to turn the genie of play, the instinct to thrill and entertain, into a tool to teach and inspire others in their care?”

It’s by no means a guarantee, Hughes reminds us.

“Any number of men have tried to reinvent their success in team management. Alfredo Di Stefano and Ferenc Puskas, the Argentine and the Hungarian who helped make Real Madrid great in the 1950s, had only fleeting and decidedly moderate success as coaches.”

In fact, it’s rare in any sport that the most talented, gifted players become good coaches. More often it is the average player who grows into an effective teacher. Often these players have fewer natural gifts fueling their success as players, and therefore must compensate on the field by being smarter, more mentally astute and analytical. This makes them better coaches later on. Two examples from the basketball world: Pat Riley and Phil Jackson. Both were role players on top teams in the N.B.A. But both men took their experience and court savvy and created fabulously successful coaching careers.

Maradona may be aided by such men. Carlos Bilardo, Maradona’s former coach on the national team, will be the manager. Sergio Batista, a hard-nosed player on the 1986 World Cup team who was less talented than many of his contemporaries, has proven himself as a coach at the youth level, leading Argentina to a second consecutive gold medal in the Olympics. He and Jose Luis Brown were expected to be named assistant coaches. They’d provide a learned and stabilizing influence which could be combined with Maradona’s inspiration.

But the decision on assistants has been held up. The Associated Press reports that Maradona preferred Oscar Ruggeri and his friend Alejandro Mancuso. “We still don’t have it resolved,” Maradona said, according to the A.P. “What we’re looking for with Carlos is that the (new coaching staff) be made of iron, that they’re ready to work and that they will accept orders from the head guy, which is me.”

An Earthly Realm for a Soccer God

Left, Adalberto Roque/AFP-Getty; Right, Alexander Hassenstein/Getty Images
Diego Maradona has struggled with drugs, alcohol and obesity in recent years, left. Argentina now hopes that he can lead the team back to victory.